Prime Tenderloin Steak

Prime Tenderloin Steak

Select Pieces
/
  • Always cut-to-order by an artisanal butcher
  • Free delivery on orders over $250

 

"A really exquisite filet.”

The Quick Facts on Our Prime Tenderloin Steak

  • 2 pieces per package
  • 100% prime-grade beef
  • Aged 30 days
  • Hand cut to order 

Does it get any better than a prime tenderloin steak? At prime - the highest grade for beef in North America - these steaks have a delicate balance of flavourful marbling while still being lean, making it the perfect cut for a filet mignon.

Goes Great With...

Serve this beautiful filet with a dry red wine and your favorite starch and greens.

Our Preferred Preparation for a Prime Tenderloin Steak 

Keep it simple and let this tenderloin steak speak for itself. We particularly love a pan-fried preparation, always striving for that lovely crusty sear on the outer edges.

    How It Ships

    Our prime tenderloin steaks are cut fresh to order, then immediately vacuum sealed and sent directly to your door within 12-24 hours of your order.

    Other Beef Tenderloin Cuts

    The Prime Cannon Cut Tenderloin and Japanese Wagyu Tenderloin Steak are excellent alternatives to the Prime Tenderloin Steak, each offering a uniquely luxurious texture and rich flavor profile. If you're looking for a natural, earthy flavor, the Local Natural Whole Beef Tenderloin and 100% Grass Fed Tenderloin Steak are superb choices. These cuts stand out with their distinctive flavors, a result of their unique rearing and feeding practices. Here are some other beef tenderloin cuts we offer:

    Perfect Pairings for Our Prime Tenderloin

    Our bone-in rib steak needs sides that complement its bold flavour. From crispy bites to fresh greens, these pairings make every mouthful even better:

    • Crispy tallow potatoes: Golden, crunchy, and cooked in beef fat, they’re the ultimate sidekick to a rich, juicy steak.
    • Caesar salad: Crisp romaine, garlicky dressing, and sharp parmesan bring just the right amount of freshness to balance out the rib steak’s depth.
    • Roasted mushrooms: Earthy and buttery, they soak up every drop of flavour and round out your plate beautifully.
    • Creamed spinach: Silky and savoury, this steakhouse classic adds richness without stealing the spotlight.
    • Charred asparagus: With a little lemon and a hint of smoke, it cuts through the marbling and brightens every bite.

    How We Craft the Ideal Tenderloin Experience

    Tenderloin steaks shine with simple preparation. Here’s how we like to cook them for the most delicious steakhouse experience at home:

    Bring to room temperature

    Take the steaks out of the fridge about 20–30 minutes before cooking so they sear evenly.

    Season simply

    A generous sprinkle ofsea saltand freshly cracked black pepper is all you need.

    Sear in a hot skillet

    Heat a cast iron or heavy pan over medium-high, then sear each side for 2–3 minutes until a golden crust forms.

    Add butter and aromatics

    In the last minute, baste with melted butter, garlic, and thyme for extra richness.

    Finish to medium-rare

    Reduce the heat slightly and cook until the internal temperature reaches 130°F for a tender, pink centre.

    Rest before serving

    Let the steaks sit for 5 minutes to lock in juices before slicing and serving.

    From Our Butcher’s Counter to Your Kitchen

    Our USDA Prime tenderloin is shipped fresh from our butcher’s block, carefully packed so it arrives at your kitchen in perfect condition:

    • Hand-cut to order and prepared by our butchers the same day it’s packed.
    • Vacuum-sealed at peak freshness to lock in natural juices and tenderness.
    • Insulated, temperature-controlled packaging: Ice packs and sturdy boxes keep your order cold and safe in transit.
    • Fast delivery across the GTA: Toronto, Mississauga, Vaughan, Scarborough, and surrounding areas within 12–24 hours.
    • Convenient storage: Cook within the week or freeze to enjoy later without losing quality.

    What Shoppers Like You Are Asking

    A heavy pan like cast iron or a hot grill is best for getting a perfect sear, but any sturdy skillet will work. Add tongs and a meat thermometer, and you’re all set to cook a flawless steak.

    USDA Prime has the highest level of marbling, which means more tenderness, juiciness, and flavour compared to USDA Choice. It’s the same quality you’ll find served at top steakhouses.

    Filet mignon is a specific steak cut from the tenderloin, while tenderloin refers to the larger primal cut that contains it. Both are exceptionally tender, but filet mignon is often considered the most delicate, while the full tenderloin offers more flavour.